Diets and Treatment Options Affect Each of Us Differently

Diets and Treatment Options Affect Each of Us Differently
My last article, “Crohn’s Disease and Diet: There Is No Magic Solution,” seems to have caused some disturbances and backlash. This was never the intention. Rather, I wanted others to remember that each patient is different, there are symptoms beyond digestion, and there is yet to be a Crohn’s disease cure. So, here, I wanted

Knowledge is power when living with IBD.

Get access to the web’s leading IBD news & insights for as little as 16¢/day.
Subscribe or to access all post and page content.

6 comments

  1. Alexandra says:

    Your previous article didn’t “seem” to cause disturbances, it did, mainly because you dismissed treatments that included diet, because that didn’t work for you. I think most IBD sufferers today are better informed than to think diet or lifestyle caused their disease, but many do know that diet and lifestyle, with or without drugs, can effectively treat their disease. Treatment is all we have…until there is a cure. Treatments can make a patient asymptomatic, leaving the underlying inflammation there to cause long-term damage, and finding the right treatment is not the same for everyone. It’s not wrong to try, just because it’s not a cure.

    • Mary Horsley says:

      Alexandra, I thank you for reaching out. But I disagree. While things may work for some, that is not what treatment is. None of these options are ‘treatments’ for all IBD sufferers, they are just management for a few until the next thing comes. If my article caused disturbances with you, that was not my intention, but I do not apologize for my opinion or my personal patient perspective and the journey I have had. Each article is from my viewpoint. Diet was not a treatment for me and it is not a treatment for Crohn’s, just like many drugs haven’t been a treatment for me. These are just ways of IBD management. Yes, you can be asymptomatic, but for me, does diet help my personal joint pain? My personal skin sores? My personal fatigue, all over pain I experience or my own rectal bleeding? No, it doesnt. Diet does not curb wall thickening or abscess development. I didnt have 2 rectal surgeries because of diet or lifestyle. Fistulas are not caused or helped by diet. And my lifestyle choices do not either. I do not do this to myself. I never said it was wrong to try these things, just that it not the fix all or cure all. Thanks.

        • Mary Horsley says:

          There is no known proof or evidence that diet is considered a ‘treatment’ for Crohn’s or IBD. It takes more than a few claims or a small percentage of those who have been ‘helped’ to prove anything, we’re talking several longterm studies with control groups, regular bloodwork, regular colonoscopies, etc. Anything less isn’t proof.

          I want to believe that diet and lifestyle changes are the answer but I am also not looking for something that will improve my symptoms if on the inside, this disease is still wreaking havoc on my intestines. While I would rather these diets work before going on biologic drugs, I do not want to waste my time following these “cures” that people claim are cures just because they seem to “feel” better and not because a scope showed healing or an improved bowel state.

          Also, you only chose the first ‘definition’ of treatment without posting the second, you cannot pick and choose. “Treatment: a session of medical care or the administration of a dose of medicine; the combating of a disease or disorder.” Diet does not combat IBD.

          Again, thanks for your opinion. This article is my opinion and personal journey. ‘Enough said.’

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *